Jay Tea, over at Wizbang, has put up a fairly asinine post today.
I've aspired to be more of a "thinker" than a "linker." It's largely
a matter of practicality for me; I don't have the sources to come up
with great scoops, nor do I have the time to track down items and be
the first to "break" them. What I can do is look at events and ruminate
about them, take my time to properly ponder them, and then bloviate at
my leisure.
But one thing I've noticed is that the right tends to dominate the
"thinkers" category. There's the above-mentioned (and much missed)
Steven Den Beste, Wretchard, Austin Bay, Will Franklin, Bill Whittle, and the non-blogging Victor Davis Hansen, just to name a few.
But where are the thinkers of the left? Where are the serious
essayists, the scholars, the contemplators who would provide balance to
the sheer intellectual power of the above?
There options to reply with are, of course, myriad. And I thought I'd give him a list.
Lets just start with some of the members of the left who were, I don't know, nominated for "Best Liberal Weblog of 2004" (a list put together by none other than Jay Tea's own blog, Wizbang).
John Aravosis at Americablog (though I'll admit that he may be a bit too activist for Jay Tea's taste)
Want the best essayist on the left, in my opinion? How about Matt Yglesias?
You don't know who David Neiwert is? Allow me to help.
How about economics? Try Brad DeLong.
Me thinks you aren't trying hard enough to find...wait, how did you put it? "...reasonable, logical, intelligent opinions that disagree with my own." So desperate, in fact, that you couldn't be bothered to consult a list put together by your own website.
But let me help with some more.
There's Alley, who's the best essayist I read on the real issues facing women today.
Of course, there's Josh Marshall (but I'm sure you'll find something wrong with him...)
How about the second coming of Matt Yglesias, Ezra Klein?
I'm sure that Jay Tea will find something wrong with all of these excellent writers. When he does, I challenge you all to remind him that he was the one that wanted real discussion and real discourse with people that disagree with him. These people will disagree with him, for certain.
Something tells me that very fact will be what Jay Tea eventually finds to declare these people unacceptable.
UPDATE: I encourage you all to go over to Jay Tea's post and, civilly, give him examples of who you think might be worth his while to read.
Recent Comments